Wednesday 18 February 2015

And They Lived Duskily Ever After - pt II

But then marriage also becomes some sort of skin color goal. I remember reading a matrimonial ad from this well-educated guy, working in America whose marital ambitions lay in the direction of possessing a wife with the qualities “Fair and Slim”. It doesn’t matter how much she has studied, where she works, what her hobbies are etc. Everything else is “swalpa adjust maadi-ed", but we can never compromise on fair skin. Ayyo. 

But this is all so common, even today.  I have heard people call my friend good-looking and the wistfully hope that he might have been fairer. My nanny, when I was a child, would never leave the house, even to open the gate, without putting on skin whitening cream and every day, I see around fifty women  walking around with congealed turmeric on the side of their faces, miraculously hoping for a “cure” to dark skin. However, if one looks at this phenomenon, and studies it from a more macro perspective, it becomes evident that these ideas are being validated and encouraged, not to mention - built into our value systems by our media and other instruments of pop culture.

Cinema actresses are congratulated for being dusky and still bold, brave and beautiful and skin lightening creams are named things like Fair and Lovely. Fair and Lovely, for example, thrives on ad campaigns that equate fairness to being lovely, beautiful, happy and successful. A miserable dusky woman, after four weeks of diligent “Fair and Lovely” application is magically transformed into a successful billboard model. Now that she is fair, she can conquer the world – be happy, successful and beautiful.  In a few years, this woman, still fair of course, has given birth to two fair children - one boy and one girl and does miracles in the kitchen every morning, cooking one breakfast each for every individual in the household, not one strand of hair out of place while simultaneously running a successful business and making happy faces with Kissan ketchup on her children’s lunch.

 A recent ad film for a big jewellery brand was considered “groundbreaking” as it portrayed a bride who was not very fair. She was a beautiful woman, but the first thing that people picked up on was that she was not fair. The fact that in the 21st century, in a brown skinned country, using a brown skinned woman in an ad is considered revolutionary, is an accurate statement about the extent to which ‘fair is good', as a notion, has infiltrated our systems. Marriage requirements and bio/profiles specifically state “fairness” as one of the virtues necessary for being a good spouse.  In movies, the darker characters are always the “ugly” best friend or the unattractive brother/sister-or the villain. Women like Nandita Das and Konkana Sen are called “unconventionally beautiful”, because they are beautiful, yes, but not fair or even worse, they are sometimes specifically addressed as “dusky beauty”, as opposed to having the privilege of being referred to as just “beauty”- a privilege reserved for fair women.

Everyday, numerous products flood our markets and eventually our houses, each promising lightening, whitening and beautifying and people lap these up as fast as is physically possible – soaps, lotions and gels. 

Then again, I can’t claim pious disdain for all these products. I’ve used these creams too, for removing tan lines and marks left by my numerous acne tragedies, but, I have never felt unhappy with the color of my skin. My complexion makes me miserable all the time since pimples take it upon themselves to visit regularly, but never my skin color. Even when dark and beautiful, all our famous actors and actresses, cake on makeup to look fairer, ensuring that - all that the audience saw for a long time is that famous people were fair, fair people were moneyed and moneyed people were happy.

Interestingly, Vedic literature as a scripture of the predominant Indian religion of Hinduism has always alluded to the fact that its most beautiful characters were always dark – Draupadi, Krishna, Rama etc. Despite worshipping dark skinned gods, who have always been described as dark skinned, it is odd that Hindus, especially still hold onto notions of skin and beauty. Aryans, when they ruled India, intermarried with the native Indians and there is not much evidence of  discrimination and a lust for fairness till the period of  colonialism . Perhaps, the allusion to the dark skinned natives as barbaric and savages, is a connotation that we culturally attached to our skin. Perhaps, at least in Hindu society, even  Goddesses like Sarasvati and Parvathi – the Goddesses of learning, music and knowledge are always depicted as fair whereas goddesses like Kali or Durga, who are considered more “aggressive” and more “bloodthirsty and rustic” are dark skinned.

 Even South Indian films, had and to a large extent still have qualms about using a dark skinned heroine. They may even go to the extent of bringing in a woman from another country - but! will not use a dark skinned heroine. Then again, its heroes are usually dark skinned. There is a huge double standard, especially for women to be fair possibly because, at least in South India, being fair is alluded to being more “cultured” and “feminine”. Now, however , Campaigns like “Dark is Beautiful” are gaining followers and more and more actors like Deepika Padukone and Vidya Balan – who are dusky- are making it big in the film industry. One can only hope that these campaigns help  our transitioning into a culture, which not only accepts the traits that are characteristic to, but embraces them. If brown skinned people cannot be brown skinned in a brown skinned country, where else can they be who they are and be who they are proudly? 

Till then, we must arm ourselves with Vicco Turmeric cream and fend off insults about our skin like we swat fruit flies away from our dining tables. Proudly and duskily. Till the very end.

Avani Konduri

28 comments:

  1. It is very unfortunate how self image, self confidence and success get attributed to the color of skin! This is a global phenomenon and is clearly seen in racial profiling that exists world over. It is heartening to see more and more youngsters such as you challenging this both in the personal as well as the social domain.

    ReplyDelete
  2. It is very unfortunate how self image, self confidence and success get attributed to the color of skin! This is a global phenomenon and is clearly seen in racial profiling that exists world over. It is heartening to see more and more youngsters such as you challenging this both in the personal as well as the social domain.

    ReplyDelete
  3. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Good show, well written. Just wanted to add that Kali, the Dark One, actually refers to her hidden nature - spiritually speaking. Her form, color and manner are allegorical references to the concealed, mystic power of nature.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you so much. Yes, indeed. I completely agree with you. Thank you for pointing that out. In context to your reply, when these celestial, divine beings are described, they have reserved for them, words like "terrible beauty" which like you pointed out, is a play on both the innate characteristics of their divinity as well as the extent of their power. However, these innate characteristics of their power as being intense and warrior like and their nature as gods being as an annihilator of sorts, who are involved with complete destruction of evil and are very openly "aggressive" are characteristics that are associated with being dark.

      Keep Reading :D

      Delete
    2. Sorry, I forgot to add... In class the other day, we were talking about some countries, in Africa I believe, where "their" Jesus is black. This can be examined to be a result of their ability to relate to a "black Jesus" better as one of their own. Interestingly, even goddesses like Mariyamma etc and more local, community gods are also darker in nature - be explained by similar logic.

      Delete
    3. * Which can be explained through/by similar logic

      Delete
  5. Well said Agami. Very meaningful writing like your title. Sharing same similar thoughts about fairness, Creams, and the promoting stories of the fairness creams.Like they said in the ads fair skin should be your goal and you will be the most successful person in the glamour field.
    Silly provocations to misguide the people. Your opinions are very simple and down to earth. Congratulations for Agami. Good luck for the upcoming writings.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you for reading ! I am glad to find so many like-minded people here : D

      Delete
  6. Very meaningful. . good work

    ReplyDelete
  7. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Talking about the criteria for a 'perfect bride', A similar incident happened with one of my cousins. When the groom's side of the family visited my cousin's house to schedule the wedding and reception dates, her sister in law specified that she (my cousin) must take 'special' care of her skin tone because otherwise the 'match will not look good' on the stage.

    Being a gujarati with a wheatish tone, I myself have been provided with turmeric face packs and fairness creams from relatives and neighbours in order to cure my color and get good alliance- the only thing I have taken birth for and have been awaiting since then.

    We researched on the similar topic last year. The study concluded that almost 60% of the subjects felt confident about their looks when they applied fairness creams.

    According to me, the "fair is beautiful and beautiful is good" stereotype will prevail until the mindset of people itself is changed. Unless the people with darker skin tone themselves are content and convinced that they are beautiful, society (especially, the concerned neighbours and adorable relatives) will continue to worry about them and will make efforts to 'help' them become beautiful thereby giving further to boost their self esteem.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I love the sarcasm and cynicism in your words and wholeheartedly support your statements. Change has to start with mindsets changing and unfortunately in this case, it is the mindset of people who have darker skin that needs to change- which needs to happen simultaneously and almost cyclically, with a change in the general mindset of people.

      And to the snarky feminist (or humanist) in you, my first thought when I was told I was lucky my skin tone was not darker than what it is, since I can now get a good husband, was "this is exactly why my mother gave birth to me after so much hard labour - so that i could exist (fairly or darkly depending on past sin) and get married (to a fair or dark man depending on my luck).

      People and their priorities I tell you !!

      Thank for reading :D

      Delete
    2. My punctuation is all over the place!! sorry

      *Thanks for reading

      Delete
  9. An honest and relevant article. Campaigns such as'Dark is Beautiful' should be supported by all, to end the superficial discrimination that exists in our society. Just wanted to point out that even Deepika Padukone, although considered to be a dusky beauty has endorsed a "fairness product"(Garnier, I think).
    Last year the Central Consumer Protection Council declared that if any product claims are not true, then the consumer can sue the company and the brand ambassador (celebrities) are obligated to pay part of the compensation, I think legislations such as this one would hopefully not only protect the consumers' interests but also help change the mindset of people in the long run.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks a lot! Yes, I remember reading about the CCPC ruling and I completely agree with it. As consumers, I think it is important that we are supported and protected by such legislations. Oh the irony of Deepika Padukone endorsing fairness ! If I am not misaken, Illeana D'Cruz also endorses some fairness brand and who can forget Shahrukh Khan's 'Fair and Handsome" thing.

      Thank you very much, keep reading ::D

      Delete
  10. Well said! I completely agree.... It's unfortunate how people tend to think... Let's hope that it changes soon! Everyone is beautiful the way they are :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Absolutely! Unfortunately, the change is going to very snail-paced - but as long as there is some change, who are we to complain. Thanks a lot Shobhana!

      Delete
    2. Exactly! Let's just hope that snail-paced progress does do some good in the future! And you're most welcome :D

      Delete
  11. The change of mindset could take a few more years I'm guessing

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. With the pace that we are going now, it will definitely take ages.

      Delete
  12. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  13. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  14. South Indians are perhaps the most racist groups! The cosmetic industry takes us on an elephantine ride! Gandhi said perhaps tongue in cheek that when God baked apple some came overdone and see uncooked! The correct dish came out a beautiful brown! Rathna

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Absolutely and our mindset is such that our need to be fair, is greater than our comprehension of being taken for a ride. Thank you for reading :D

      Delete
  15. I love the way u write... Good job... It is ironic indeed that in a country like India which is proud of its diversity we still can't get over the bleached look!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks a lot Rashmi. Yes,indeed it is ironic. Keep reading! :D

      Delete
  16. Bias about Fair skin, red skin, or white skin is very common and we come accross blunt comments about a person's colour. People making the comments do not hesitate to express and do not think about offending others. Parents discriminating between children with different skins are not uncommon.

    ReplyDelete